3rd August 2010
Good morning Dr. Saraswat Ji
Enclosed please find the recommendation of Investigation Officer, Sr Public Prosecutor & SP, CBI submitted vide CBI report No.PE-3(A) /2001, which I received against my RTI reply No 4798/8/1/2010/RTI Act-05/Vol-50/CBI/LZ/DAD dated 30/07/2010.
Final Recommendations of IO Para 18 of above report
“However, I am of view that department action for major penalty be initiated against Dr.A.S.Bains, Director, DEAL, Dehradun for overlooking the facts that procurement of———- should have been made on the basis of a single tender basis in which he was not competent to approve of purchase. The approval should be obtained from the competent authority. I am also recommended banning of M/S India Satcom Ltd. with DRDO, Ministry of Defence as well as with other Government Departments.” – Akhil Kaushik, Inspector of Police, CBI/ SPE/ Dehradun Date 20/04/2002
Recommendation of Sr.PP
“On the allegation as recommended by IO the Sr. Public Prosecutor of the branch has recommended RDA major penalty against Dr.A.S.Bains, Director, DEAL and D.K.Gangopadhyay, indenter of ——— for irregularities as mentioned above. He has also agreed to the recommendation of IO for banning of M/s India Satcom Ltd on the said allegation.”
Recommendation of SP,CBI,SPE, Dehradun page 165 Para-5
“Keeping in view what has been discussed above, I endorse the view of IO and Sr. PP for RDA major penalty against S/Shri .A.S.Bains, Director, DEAL and D.K.Gangopadhyay, indenter of ——— for irregularities as mentioned above. I also agree to the recommendation of IO and Sr.PP for banning of M/S India Satcom Ltd.
Such action as deemed fit is also recomonded against S/Shri S. Halder, Raghuvir Singh and GC Pandey all official of DEAL and S/Shri H R Sharma, representative of DMM (DRDO HQ), New Delhi and PC Verma, Sc’G’, IRDE, Dehradun” – HC BIsht, Supdt. Of Police, CBI, SPE, Dehradun Date 30/05/2002
Two special PARA of report is
The recommendation of the TPC was approved by Director and the statement of case was prepared for obtaining sanction for approval of purchase from competetent authority i.e SA to RM as in case of single tender the financial competence of Director of Lab is restricted to Rs 1 Lakh. The statement of case put up DRDO under the signature of Dr.AS Bains and Dr.KD Nayak dt 7th Oct 1997 sate that the requirement of………
The deal for the purchase was approved by the then SA to RM Dr.APJ Abul Kalam. However the only bone of connection is fact that when the supplier asked for change of nomenclature and replacing the word down convertor with integrated circuit, Dr AS Bains, director of the lab had approved of the TPC recommendation and have not referred this matter of change of nomenclature to SA to RM as the deal was approved by him. However, comment to mention that as per scientist of SSPL the down convertor is very specialized integrated circuit. The act of Dr.AS Bains in approving the change of nomenclature and not referring to DRDO Hqrs is not justified.
May I ask you a question?
As a whistle blower I was the one who reported the criminal act being done by close associate
of then SA to RM, Dr VK Atre, even the SA to RM was kept in dark.
Then why I was made victim?
Why the criminals got outstanding promotions and freed scot free?
The entire team of so called scientists who were engaged in this criminal act were received the patronage of the successive SA to RM. Like Dr.KD Nayak who had in his kitty several engagements financial irregularities in number of project/procurement when he was in DEAL. With this biodata Dr.Atre, Dr Natrajan and Dr Saraswat all gave protection to him.
Which was a crime?
Encouragement in financial irregularities, which is directly responsible for the failure of DRDO output.
I as whistle blower did a mistake.
Please convinced me DRDO has given me penalty or reward.
Prabhu Dayal Dandriyal
21-Sunderwala, Raipur, Dehradun-248008
Phone – 2787750, Mobile- 9411114879,
1. Smt. Sonia Gandhi, Chairperson, United Progressive Alliance Fax no.23018651
2. Defence Minister Fax No 011- 23015403
3. Director, DRDL Fax No.040-24340017
4. Dr.Prahlada, CC (R&D)
5. Director, DEAL Fax No 2787265/2787190
6. Director IRDE Fax No. 2787161