Subject: Request to investigate the complaint against Dr A K Tyagi, CPIO, DRDO Hqrs Scientist’F’,DRDO, Ministry of Defence.
Reference: Vide CVC letter No 011/DEF/018-121962 date 17/03/2011 complaint forwarded to CVO, Ministry of Defence, South Block.
Sir,
A complaint sent to CVC against Dr A K Tyagi, CPIO, DRDO Hqrs Scientist’F’, DRDO, Ministry of Defence, New Delhi on 10th Nov 2010, Copy enclosed for your ready reference.
The CVC registered the case vide complain no 569/11/9 and further sent to CVO, Ministry of Defence, South Block vide CVC letter No 011/DEF/018-121962 date 15/03/2011(Copy enclosed)
Further in between I have sent an RTI request to DIAT, DRDO, Pune to get more input on the subject matter. (Copy enclosed)
I have received information that was enough to prove the irregularities in procurement and payment to vendors. (Copy enclosed)
Further Mr. Rajiv Chauhan, Advocate filed one more RTI and requested the details, after CIC intervention DIAT, DRDO provide the some documents for inspection related to procurement of online magazine costing around 22 lakhs plus. Copy of RTI and related information which we received from DIAT DRDO are enclosed herewith as evidences.
DRDO’s procurement practices are the most illogical and in the name secrecy DRDO is fooling the whole nation and in this act CDA is also equally responsible, in some cases knowingly, or in some cases unknowingly, because in the name of technology DRDO scientists are easily able to fool them.
This is a very small case of few lakhs or nearly 1.5 crores but it will show you the mechanism of how DRDO scientists are making money and fooling the system.
The ink signed order copy is not available in the department and the payment of more than 22 lakhs was done.
Like online ‘Nature Magazine” subscription available online, all the procurement papers i.e. order copy and other related papers in files are scanned papers.
Main questions in Dr. A K Tyagi case
1. Where is the ink-signed order copy of Online Nature Magazine?
2. Without ink signed order copy of Online Nature Magazine, how JCDA, Pune released the payments?
3. Are any records in DIAT, Library available which can show how many persons logged with Online Nature Magazine?
4. The observations of DIAT, DRDO enquiry committee against Dr. A K Tyagi still unanswered?
i. To understand the existing procedure for procurement of Books by Library, it was necessary to go through basis of existing procedure, record and files to related to procurement. In absence of OI/C,IC&L very limited records made available by Library and after arrival of OI/C,IC&L access to information and records was totally denied to the Board of Officers.
ii. Existing Procedure and Anomalies- the following is observed by Board of Officers.
i) OI/C,IC&L places demand directly to vendors after approval by Library Committee. There is no procedure of quotation/negotiation followed. it is noted that as per terms and conditions no discounts have been asked.
ii) Order has been placed on single tender basis
iii. During limited observations it was seen that Books were accepted at higher prices than the order/approval price by the purchase committee.
iv. No proof of price is being put up to the purchase Committee for approval.
v. Firm Orders are being placed by OI/C,IC&L without bidding/negotiation
vi. Vendors to whom orders are being placed are not registered. As per purchase procedure orders of only up to Rs 5000/- can be placed to unregistered vendors. This rule is not followed.
vii. In our limited inquiry, we observed that large numbers of books were
viii. Accepted at much higher price. We site few example-
a) Book ordered for Rs 6029.07 was procured for price Rs 81,936.00
b) Book ordered for Rs 13,156.00 was procured for price Rs 27,362.68
c) Book ordered for Rs 40,000.00 was procured for price Rs 3,60,00.00
d) Book ordered for Rs 3,292.24 was procured for price Rs 5,233.09
ix. We did not find any justification in orders or Terms & Conditions to accept such high billing prices for payment to vendors.
x. OI/C,IC&L did not conduct independent investigation regarding over valued books supplied by the vendors for their correct price.
xi. We found such number of cases where over payment was cleaned by OI/C, IC&L and Finance Officer without amendment or without bringing to notice of approving authority or VC
xii. We did not find any power vested to OI/C,IC&L, Finance Officer to clear the over payment cases.
xiii. Before payment to vendors, pre-auditing is mandatory (as per purchase procedure) No such pre auditing mechanism is found resulting in escaping the over payment cases from scrutiny and corrective action. We did not find any document or authority to exempt from pre –auditing.
xiv. Functioning of Library in case Library procurement was found devoid of adequate check and balance and control mechanism. We can conclude that OI/C,IC&L and Finance Officer flouted the principle of FR-21
5. Who is saving the culprit?
As we are aware that now some cases of DRDO were taken up seriously with efforts, like Dr. Arun Kumar, Dr. S M Veerabhadrappa, etc.
We hope that you will take this matter seriously and personally because it was pending since 15/03/2011 in CVO, Ministry of Defence.
Regards
Prabhu Dayal Dandriyal 21-Sunderwala, Raipur Dehradun-248008 Uttarakhand Cell No- 9411114879, Landline- 0135-2787750e-mail- prabhudoon@gmail.com , website : www.corruptionindrdo.com
Copy Enclosed-
- Copy of complaint sent to CVC against Dr A K Tyagi
- Copy of CVC letter dated 15/03/2011
- Copy of CVC Letter dated 17/03/2011
- Copy of RTI to DIAT, DRDO, Pune
- Copy of Reply of DIAT, DRDO, Pune
- Copy of RTI request of Dr Rajiv Chauhan & CIC decision
- Copy of procurement papers received during inspection at DIAT, DRDO, Pune
Copy of complaint sent to CVC against Dr A K Tyagi
Date -10th Nov 2010 To The Chief Vigilance Commissioner Satarkata Bhavan A-Block GPO Complex INA New delhi : 110023Complaint is being lodged against
Name – Dr.A K Tyagi, Tele 23007453
Designation- DRDO – Scientist ‘F’, CPIO, Head, RTI Cell, 314 A, DRDO Bhawan, Rajaji Marg, New Delhi – 110105
Dr. A.K.Tyagi, Scientist ‘F’, Head, RTI Cell, DRDO previously posted in Defence Institute of Advanced Technology, (DIAT), Deemed University. Defence Institute of Advanced (Deemed University) is a premier academic institute functioning under the aegis of Defence Research & Development Organization
Dr. A.K.Tyagi worked in DIAT as O I/C(Officer In-Charge), IC&L(Information Center & Library) and Finance Officer during his posting.
He has violated the all procurement norms laid by DRDO authority vide there Revised Edition 1999, DRDO manual of Procedure for Management of Library & Technical Information Centers. – DRDO Hqrs, Ministry of Defence.
Page No – 25 Para 4.2.3 No 4 Terms for procurement of books
Page No – 33 Para 4.3.4 Terms for procurement of periodical publication
Above procedure were violated by Dr A.K Tyagi in his all procurements and misappropriate the government funds and misinterpreted the government rules for minting money for himself and as well as for his god fathers.
The book purchase in DRDO the approval of library committee is obtain which selects the useful book/journals and then the normal purchasing procedure is followed the quotations are called and the lowest bidder gets the order.
There are few publisher are whose books/journals have standard price and when order is placed it goes directly to publisher.
In Dr A K Tyagi cases most of orders were placed to local vendors in single tender basis. When the purchases of books by violating the all the rules Dr A K Tyagi surpassed the all the records and the budget limit was crossed five times( 30 Laks to 1.5 Corers). This action was noticed by all the DIAT officials and an inquiry committee was framed. The committee constituted by then Vice Chancellor a senior officer as chairman and two officer as board member,. When the committee starts the investigation most of the documents were denied by Dr A K Tyagi, somehow, the inquiry committee submitted its report. The amount of corruption was good enough to punish the official but as usual God father culture prevailing in DRDO helped him and gave him safe passage by transferring to DRDO Hqrs.
The God Father guide him to commit the corrupt practice and got protected by none other than Dr W Selvamurthy, CC R&D,DRDO.
With his blessing he purchased Nature journal, nature publishing group, 4 Crinan Street, London, United Kingdom via local vendor for Rs 25 Lakhs
Facts : Till date nobody from DIAT has seen the Nature Journal
This journal was not useful for DIAT as the same deals with life sciences and DIAT area is ARMAMENT ENGINEERING, APPLIED MATHEMATICS, METALLURGY, COMPUTER ENGINEERING, APPLIED PHYSICS, AEROSPACE ENGINEERING, MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, EXPLOSIVES & APPLIED CHEMISTRY, ELECTRONICS
The chairman for the Nature Journal procurement was Vigilance Officer of DIAT who approved this procurement from local vendor.
In other cases the books/journals orders were recommended in dollars but Dr.A K Tyagi made payment in Pounds/Euro for the same procurement and bill was raised by with the help local vendors. Example – if book cost was approved by library committee in $ 360but when the payment was done that is 360 Pounds
The inquiry constituted to address this issue inspire of giving punishment the God Father Dr W Selvamurthy, CC R&D,DRDO than CC (HR) gave him safe passage and now DRDO Hqrs made him CPIO,DRDO Hqrs, Head RTI Cell and the best part of this
DRDO is exempted from RTI Act 2005 of Schedule-II only corruption & human right RTI entertained by DRDO so one can imagine the DRDO find most suitable corrupt official for the handling of RTI issues.
The finding of inquiry committee of DIAT (Board of Three Senior Officers)
1. Observations – To understand the existing procedure for procurement of Books by Library, it was necessary to go through basis of existing procedure, record and files to related to procurement. In absence of OI/C,IC&L very limited records made available by Library and after arrival of OI/C,IC&L access to information and records was totally denied to the Board of Officers.
2. Existing Procedure and Anomalies- the following is observed by Board of Officers.
i) OI/C,IC&L places demand directly to vendors after approval by Library Committee. There is no procedure of quotation/negotiation followed. it is noted that as per terms and conditions no discounts have been asked.
ii) Order has been placed on single tender basis
iii) During limited observations it was seen that Books were accepted at higher prices than the order/approval price by the purchase committee.
iv) No proof of price is being put up to the purchase Committee for approval.
v) Firm Orders are being placed by OI/C,IC&L without bidding/negotiation
vi) Vendors to whom orders are being placed are not registered. As per purchase procedure orders of only up to Rs 5000/- can be placed to unregistered vendors. This rule is not followed.
vii) In our limited inquiry, we observed that large numbers of books were
accepted at much higher price. We site few example-
a) Book ordered for Rs 6029.07 was procured for price Rs 81,936.00
b) Book ordered for Rs 13,156.00 was procured for price Rs 27,362.68
c) Book ordered for Rs 40,000.00 was procured for price Rs 3,60,00.00
d) Book ordered for Rs 3,292.24 was procured for price Rs 5,233.09
viii) We did not find any justification in orders or Terms & Conditions to accept such high billing prices for payment to venors.
ix) OI/C,IC&L did not conduct independent investigation regarding over valued books supplied by the vendors for their correct price.
x) We found such number of cases where over payment was cleaned by OI/C, IC&L and Finance Officer without amendment or without bringing to notice of approving authority or VC
xi) We did not find any power vested to OI/C,IC&L, Finance Officer to clear the over payment cases.
xii) Before payment to vendors, pre-auditing is mandatory (as per purchase procedure) No such pre auditing mechanism is found resulting in escaping the over payment cases from scrutiny and corrective action. We did not find any document or authority to exempt from pre –auditing.
xiii) Functioning of Library in case Library procurement was found devoid of adequate check and balance and control mechanism. We can conclude that OI/C,IC&L and Finance Officer flouted the principle of FR-21
Prabhu Dayal Dandriyal 21-Sunderwala, Raipur Dehradun-248008 Uttarakhand Cell No- 9411114879, Landline- 0135-2787750 e-mail- prabhu@dandriyal.com Copy of CVC letter dated 15/03/2011
CVC letter dated 15/03/2011
Copy of CVC letter dated 17/03/2011
CVC letter dated 17/03/2011
Copy of RTI to DIAT, DRDO, Pune
To Date 15th February 2011 The CPIO No RTI/DIAT/HARASS/14/2/2011Defence Institute of Armment Technology (DIAT)
Simhagad Road, Girinagar
Pune-411 025
Hello,
Kindly provide me with the following information requested under purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005. In respect of online subscription of Nature magazine by DIAT, Pune
- The copy of order of online subscription for NATURE magazine. With terms & condition
- The copy of demand initiative for Nature magazine if any.
- Copy of recommendation if any by approval committee of library.
- Copy of renewal of subscription if any
- Present status of subscription.
Note: – above required information is directly related to corruption and not come under schedule – II
Find the application fee for the request attached with this application. If you feel that above requested information does not pertain to your department then please follow the provisions of Section 6(3) of the RTI act 2005. Also as per the provision of the RTI Act 2005 please provide the details (Name and Designation) of the first appellate authority w.r.t. to your department with the reply to above request, where I may require file first appeal.
I do hereby declare that I am the citizen of India. Kindly provide me with the information at the address mentioned with the application. I request you to ensure that the information is provided before expiry of 30 day period after you have received the application.
Enclosed – Rs 10 Postal Order No 60E 172113
Regards
Prabhu Dayal Dandriyal 21-Sunderwala, Raipur Dehradun-248008 Phone – 2787750, Mobile- 9411114879, e-mail id prabhu@dandriyal.com website – www.corruptionindrdo.comCopy of Reply of DIAT, DRDO, Pune
DIAT, DRDO, Pune Reply page1
DIAT,DRDO,Pune RTI Reply page 2
Copy of RTI request of Dr Rajiv Chauhan & CIC decision
CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION
Room No. 308, B-Wing, August Kranti Bhawan, Bhikaji Cama Place, New Delhi-110066
File No.CIC/LS/A/2012/001219
Appellant Shri Rajiv Chauhan
Public Authority DRDO
Date of hearing 09.08.2012
Date of decision 09.08.2012
Facts :-
1. Heard today dated 09.08.2012. Appellant present. DRDO is represented by Shri
Deepak Mishra, Scientist ‘E’
2. The appellant had filed an RTI application dated 29.10.2011 seeking information
about the purchase of certain books and other materials by the Defence Institute of Armament Technology, Pune. This information was denied to him on the ground that DRDO is an exempted organisation. During the hearing, the appellant submits that he will be satisfied if he is given inspection of the file/files relating to the order placed by Dr. A.K. Tyagi, the then Library Incharge, DIAT, Pune, for online subscription of ‘Nature Magzine’ against payment of about Rs. 25 lacs
3. The appellant also produces a copy of the letter dated 14.3.2011 of Dr. S.S.Sirurmath, University Librarian, in which he had informed the appellant that copy of order and terms and conditions of Nature Magazine(on line) were not available. He expresses surprise at this response in as much as an order of Rs. 25 lacs could not have been placed without due processing in the file.
4. In the facts and circumstances of the case, it is hereby ordered that CPIO may give inspection of all records relating to the online subscription to the appellant or his representative in 05 weeks time.
Sd/-
( M.L. Sharma )
Information Commissioner
Authenticated true copy. Additional copies of orders shall be supplied against
application and payment of the charges, prescribed under the Act, to the CPIO of this
Commission.
( K.L. Das )
Deputy Registrar
Address of parties :-
1. The Scientist ‘F’ & CPIO, DRDO, RTI Cell,
314-A, B-Block, DRDO Bhawan,
New Delhi-110105.
2. Shri Rajiv Chauhan,
1053/3, Shastri Nagar,
Meerut-250005.
The Right to Information Act, 2005
Appeal before the Central Information Commission;
Appeal No. ———————– Dated ————————
As I am aggrieved by decision of Central Public Information Officer and First Appellate
Authority, I hereby file this appeal for your kind decision.
1. Details of appellant:
1.1 Full Name: – RAJIV CHAUHAN
1.2. Full Address: R/O-1053/3, SHASTRI NAGAR, MEERUT (U.P)-250005
1.3 Phone/Cell No.: 09412628314 ; 09258045938 ; 0121-4009512;
4 Email ID: rajivchauhan89@yahoo.co.in
2. Details of Central Public Information Officer (CPIO):
2.1 Name/Designation: Dr.A.K.TYAGI ; SCIENTIST “F’ , CPIO, DRDO HQ;
2.2 Full Address: 314-A, “B’ BLOCK, DRDO BHAWAN, NEW DELHI-110105
2.3 Name of Public Authority: DRDO, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE.
IMPORTANT NOTE :-
The RTI information is related with the corruption of the CPIO of RTI Dr.A.K.TYAGI during the office-in charge ,information centre/ library & finance officer of DIAT (Defense institute of Advanced technology). So that the decision on my RTI decision given by- Deepak Mishra , Addl.Director, RTI Cell, DRDO BHAWAN , NEW DELHI-110105
3. Details of First Appellate Authority [FAA]:
3.1 Name/Designation of the FAA: Dr. ARUN KUMAR
3.2 Full Address of FAA: OS & DIRECTOR; DIRECTORATE OF PERSONNEL;
ROOM NO- 217, DRDO BHAWAN, NEW DELHI-110105
4. Dates of RTI application/first appeal:
4.1 To CPIO — 29 OCT 2011
4.2 To FAA: — 02 DEC 2011
5. Particulars of Decisions:
5.1 Reference No & Date of CPIO Decision:-
22nd NOV2011; RTI/01/2091/P/2011/0283; CPIO.DRDO HQ; NEW DELHI
5.2 Reference No & Date of FAA’s Decision:-
10 JAN 2012; RTI/02/2091/F/2011/114; Dr.Arun Kumar,OS & DOP , FAA,DRDO HQ
6. Dates of receipt of replies by appellant from:-
6.1 CPIO— 28 NOV2011
6.2 FAA: — 17 JAN 2012
7. Details of information sought:-
Kindly inform to you that Dr.A.K.Tyagi worked in DIAT (Defense Institute of Advanced Technology) as OI(office in charge),IC&L(Information centre & library) and Finance officer during his posting. Presently the CPIO at DRDO HQ, New Delhi. He has violated all procurement norms laid by DRDO authority vide there revised edition 1999,DRDO manual of Procedure for management of library & Technical Information Centers.-DRDO HQ, Ministry of Defense .Page no-25 para 4.2.3 no 4 terms for procurement of books; page no-33 para 4.3.4 terms for procurement of periodical publication. Above procedure were violated by Dr A.K Tyagi in his all procurements and misappropriate the government funds and misinterpreted the government rules for minting money for himself .The book purchase in DRDO the approval of library committee is obtain which selects the useful book/journals and then the normal purchasing procedure is followed the quotations are called and the lowest bidder gets the order. There are few publisher are whose books/journals have standard price and when order is placed it goes directly to publisher.
In Dr A K Tyagi cases most of orders were placed to local vendors in single tender basis. When the purchases of books by violating the all the rules Dr A K Tyagi surpassed the all the records and the budget limit was crossed five times( 30 Laks to 1.5 Corers). This action was noticed by all the DIAT officials and an inquiry committee was framed. The committee constituted by then Vice Chancellor a senior officer as chairman and two officer as board member,. When the committee starts the investigation most of the documents were denied by Dr A K Tyagi, somehow, the inquiry committee submitted its report. The amount of corruption was good enough to punish the official but as usual God father culture prevailing in DRDO helped him and gave him safe passage by transferring to DRDO Hqrs.
He purchased Nature journal, nature publishing group, 4 Crinan Street, London, United Kingdom via local vendor for Rs 25 Lakhs
Facts : Till date nobody from DIAT has seen the Nature Journal
This journal was not useful for DIAT as the same deals with life sciences and DIAT area is ARMAMENT ENGINEERING, APPLIED MATHEMATICS, METALLURGY, COMPUTER ENGINEERING, APPLIED PHYSICS, AEROSPACE ENGINEERING, MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, EXPLOSIVES & APPLIED CHEMISTRY, ELECTRONICS
The chairman for the Nature Journal procurement was Vigilance Officer of DIAT who approved this procurement from local vendor.
In other cases the books/journals orders were recommended in dollars but Dr.A K Tyagi made payment in Pounds/Euro for the same procurement and bill was raised by with the help local vendors. Example – if book cost was approved by library committee in $ 360 but when the payment was done that is 360 Pounds
The finding of inquiry committee of DIAT (Board of Three Senior Officers)
1. Observations – To understand the existing procedure for procurement of Books by Library, it was necessary to go through basis of existing procedure, record and files to related to procurement. In absence of OI/C,IC&L very limited records made available by Library and after arrival of OI/C,IC&L access to information and records was totally denied to the Board of Officers.
2. Existing Procedure and Anomalies- the following is observed by Board of Officers.
i) OI/C,IC&L places demand directly to vendors after approval by Library Committee. There is no procedure of quotation/negotiation followed. it is noted that as per terms and conditions no discounts have been asked.
ii) Order has been placed on single tender basis
iii) During limited observations it was seen that Books were accepted at higher prices than the order/approval price by the purchase committee.
iv) No proof of price is being put up to the purchase Committee for approval.
v) Firm Orders are being placed by OI/C,IC&L without bidding/negotiation
vi) Vendors to whom orders are being placed are not registered. As per purchase procedure orders of only up to Rs 5000/- can be placed to unregistered vendors. This rule is not followed.
vii) In our limited inquiry, we observed that large numbers of books were
accepted at much higher price. We site few example-
a) Book ordered for Rs 6029.07 was procured for price Rs 81,936.00
b) Book ordered for Rs 13,156.00 was procured for price Rs 27,362.68
c) Book ordered for Rs 40,000.00 was procured for price Rs 3,60,00.00
d) Book ordered for Rs 3,292.24 was procured for price Rs 5,233.09
viii) We did not find any justification in orders or Terms & Conditions to accept such high billing prices for payment to venors.
ix) OI/C,IC&L did not conduct independent investigation regarding over valued books supplied by the vendors for their correct price.
x) We found such number of cases where over payment was cleaned by OI/C, IC&L and Finance Officer without amendment or without bringing to notice of approving authority or VC
xi) We did not find any power vested to OI/C,IC&L, Finance Officer to clear the over payment cases.
xii) Before payment to vendors, pre-auditing is mandatory (as per purchase procedure) No such pre auditing mechanism is found resulting in escaping the over payment cases from scrutiny and corrective action. We did not find any document or authority to exempt from pre –auditing.
xiii) Functioning of Library in case Library procurement was found devoid of adequate check and balance and control mechanism. We can conclude that OI/C,IC&L and Finance Officer flouted the principle of FR-21
This is a case of the corruption so that the main object to take this information is to provide as an evidence before high power investigating officer / commission / higher courts in the interest of law and justice .
I want the following information’s as under-
S.No INFORMATION SOUGHT REPLY
1. Is it true that Dr. A.K.Tyagi worked in DIAT (Defense Institute of Advanced Technology) as OI(office in charge),IC&L(Information centre & library) and Finance officer during his posting. Presently the CPIO at DRDO HQ, New Delhi ?
Yes/No
2. Dr A K Tyagi OI/C,IC&L places demand directly to vendors after approval by Library Committee. There is no procedure of quotation / negotiation followed ? Yes/No
3. Dr A K Tyagi OI/C,IC&L has been placed orders on single tender basis? Yes/No
4. Vendors to whom orders are being placed are not
registered?
Yes/ No
5. Book cost was approved by library committee in US dollor 360 but when the payment was done that is 360 Pounds ?
Yes/No
6. Order copy and term, conditions for the nature Magazine is not available. So the order place by Dr. A.K.Tyagi for Nature Magazine verbally or in written? Pl. provide suitable reply with authentic documents.
I state that the information sought does not fall within the restriction in section 8 & 9 of the Act and to the best of my knowledge it pertains in the DRDO office contained & record. Above required information is directly related to corruption and not come under scheduled –II. I request to you please provide me the information by the speed post.
8. Brief facts of the case:-
I submitted my RTI application before the CPIO, DRDO, New Delhi on dt.29-10-2011. Cause for put up this application was the allegation of the corruption / misuse of the office by Dr.A.K.Tyagi . He violated all procurement norms laid by DRDO authority vide there revised edition 1999,DRDO manual of Procedure for management of library & Technical Information Centers.-DRDO HQ, Ministry of Defense .Page no-25 para 4.2.3 no 4 terms for procurement of books; page no-33 para 4.3.4 terms for procurement of periodical publication. Above procedure were violated by Dr A.K Tyagi in his all procurements and misappropriate the government funds and misinterpreted the government rules for minting money for himself .The book purchase in DRDO the approval of library committee is obtain which selects the useful book/journals and then the normal purchasing procedure is followed the quotations are called and the lowest bidder gets the order. There are few publisher are whose books/journals have standard price and when order is placed it goes directly to publisher. In Dr A K Tyagi cases most of orders were placed to local vendors in single tender basis. When the purchases of books by violating the all the rules Dr A K Tyagi surpassed the all the records and the budget limit was crossed five times( 30 Laks to 1.5 Corers). This action was noticed by all the DIAT officials and an inquiry committee was framed. The committee constituted by then Vice Chancellor a senior officer as chairman and two officer as board member,. When the committee starts the investigation most of the documents were denied by Dr A K Tyagi, somehow, the inquiry committee submitted its report. The amount of corruption was good enough to punish the official but as usual God father culture prevailing in DRDO helped him and gave him safe passage by transferring to DRDO Hqrs. He purchased Nature journal, nature publishing group, 4 Crinan Street, London, United Kingdom via local vendor for Rs 25 Lakhs
CPIO reply is not satisfactory and not as per the law because the RTI is related with the allegation of the corruption and not exempted under section 24(1) of the RTI Act-2005.
In Supreme Court civil Appeal no – 6454 clearly mentioned that- “37. The right to information is a cherished right. Information and right to information are intended to be formidable tools in the hands of responsible citizens to fight corruption and to bring in transparency and accountability.
The provisions of RTI Act should be enforced strictly and all efforts should be made to bring to light the necessary information under clause (b) of section 4(1) of the Act which relates to securing transparency and accountability in the working of public authorities and in discouraging corruption.”
I was not satisfied with the reply of CPIO,DRDO HQ, New Delhi, after that I submitted an appeal before FAA to take the information but the FAA of DRDO dismissed the appeal and failed to provide the information with the ref. of second schedule of the RTI Act & section 24(1) of the RTI Act-2005.
9. Reasons/grounds for this appeal:-
1- That the RTI application is related with the public information because the tenders generally published in news paper / internet for the purchasing of the books as per the DRDO manual of Procedure for management of library & Technical Information Centers.-DRDO HQ, Ministry of Defense .Page no-25 para 4.2.3 no 4 terms for procurement of books; page no-33 para 4.3.4 terms for procurement of periodical publication.
2- That this information is directly related with the corruption and misuse of the office and not come under section 24(1) of the RTI Act because the books/journals orders were recommended in dollars but Dr.A K Tyagi made payment in Pounds/Euro for the same procurement and bill was raised by with the help local vendors. Example – if book cost was approved by library committee in $ 360but when the payment was done that is 360 Pounds
3- In Dr A K Tyagi cases most of orders were placed to local vendors in single tender basis. When the purchases of books by violating the all the rules Dr A K Tyagi surpassed the all the records and the budget limit was crossed five times( 30 Laks to 1.5 Corers). This action was noticed by all the DIAT officials and an inquiry committee was framed. The committee constituted by then Vice Chancellor a senior officer as chairman and two officer as board member,. When the committee starts the investigation most of the documents were denied by Dr A K Tyagi, somehow, the inquiry committee submitted its report. The amount of corruption was good enough to punish the official but as usual God father culture prevailing in DRDO helped him and gave him safe passage by transferring to DRDO Hqrs.
4- That the main object to take this information is to provide as an evidence before High Power Investigating Officer/ Commissions / High Courts in the interest of law and justice.
10. Any other information in support of appeal:-
1- This RTI information is required to proof a corruption during the purchasing of the books / periodical publication.
2- Dr.A.K.Tyagi violated all procurement norms laid by DRDO authority vide there revised edition 1999,DRDO manual of Procedure for management of library & Technical Information Centers.-DRDO HQ, Ministry of Defense .Page no-25 para 4.2.3 no 4 terms for procurement of books; page no-33 para 4.3.4 terms for procurement of periodical publication. Above procedure were violated by Dr A.K Tyagi in his all procurements and misappropriate the government funds and misinterpreted the government rules for minting money for himself.
3- That this action was noticed by all the DIAT officials and an inquiry committee was framed. This committee was put up an adverse report to the authorities.
11. Prayer/relief sought for:-
I request your honor to pass an order to concern authority to provide the following information’s as under-
S.No INFORMATION SOUGHT REPLY
1. Is it true that Dr. A.K.Tyagi worked in DIAT (Defense Institute of Advanced Technology) as OI(office in charge),IC&L(Information centre & library) and Finance officer during his posting. Presently the CPIO at DRDO HQ, New Delhi ?
Yes/No
2. Dr A K Tyagi OI/C,IC&L places demand directly to vendors after approval by Library Committee. There is no procedure of quotation / negotiation followed ? Yes/No
3. Dr A K Tyagi OI/C,IC&L has been placed orders on single tender basis? Yes/No
4. Vendors to whom orders are being placed are not
registered?
Yes/ No
5. Book cost was approved by library committee in US dollor 360 but when the payment was done that is 360 Pounds ?
Yes/No
6. Order copy and term, conditions for the nature Magazine is not available. So the order place by Dr. A.K.Tyagi for Nature Magazine verbally or in written? Pl. provide suitable reply with authentic documents.
I state that the information sought does not fall within the restriction in section 8 & 9 of the Act and to the best of my knowledge it pertains in the DRDO office contained & record. Above required information is directly related to corruption and not come under scheduled –II. I request your honor to pass an order to concern authority to provide the information’s by the speed post.
(2)- I request your honor to pass an order in favor of the applicant as deemed fit as an any relief .
Personal Presence at hearing:- — YES
Declaration:-
I hereby state that the information and particulars given above are true to the best of my knowledge and belief. I also declare that this matter is not previously filed with this commission nor is pending with any Court or tribunal or authority.
Place: MEERUT
Date: —————-
Signature of appellant
Copy of procurement papers received during inspection at DIAT, DRDO, Pune
Very Good Sir, PPD Ji.
One DRDO corrupt Sc ‘F’ Dr.A K Tyagi (Doctor in Corruption) cheating in public fund , Very good now face to CVC & CBI case no other help by your God Father guide him to commit the corrupt practice and got protected by none other than Dr W Selvamurthy, CC R&D,DRDO.
Braking News
Viswaat Chemical (GOCO ) go Out From HEMRL no Service Extension For H Company.
Sub. Being victimize for raising the voice against corruption in Hal Agra of poor servicing of defense
a/c an-32 by untrained unqualified workman ,Email Dated 10.jan.2005, to Hon President of India,
, E-01
Ref. Ref.-Request / Complained / RTI against HAL Negligent &, Corrupted Management
2948/2012/vigi. 9/60392 dated 15-2-12
Cvc/rti/12/1061 /190067 dated 9-10-12
Cvc/rti/12/1045 /187488 dated 13-9-12
Cvc/rti/12/1010/192147 dated 20-10-12
28141/2012/vigi.9/192882 dated 29-10-12
Cvc/rti/12/1867/203383 dated 15-2-13
Cvc/rti/12/ 1867 /2040 /94 dated 26-2-13
Cvc/rti/13/ 247/212531 dated 15-5-13
.Now 123 a/c crashed of IAF in last 10 years due to unqualified / untrained eng/ technicians of HAL, it is not the matter of national wealth but also matter of precious life of pilots , I am reporting since Jan. 2005 to till date to,, Hon President of India Sh. APJ Abdul Kalam ,Smt Pritibha Patil , Parnav Mukher ji , Secretary to the gov. Of India, defense ,Sec to DDDP (HAL ) MOD , Defance Minister Parnav Mukher j i/ , Sh. AK Antony, . But, so far, No or investigation or action ordered from /Ministry, against, Chairman Hal Bangalore or waiting for more loss of National Wealth / Pilots Life / My Killing E-2
Sir,
1. Based On Email Dated 10.jan.2005,on my name to Hon President of India, corrupt and negligent HAL management ,.Stopped my entry to work spot at hal dett agra, taken revengeful action against me by discontinue my service on 16 apr.2005, by hire and fire without prior information / notice / warning before or by 31st Mar 05,.by imposing falls foolish, allegations’ on me and could not provided any documantry proof of falls , foolish, allegations imposed on me likr poor performance ,Misconduct, No work at hal agra under RTI act 2005
2. Now Corruptions in Hal exposed under RTI ACT 2005 by me, Poor servicing of AN-32 A/C by untrained / unqualified technicians / eng. at HAL Agra., Corrupt & Negligent Management Not quality conscious but no action against technician / eng / Managers proved involved in corruption under RTI ACT 2005 with documentary proof,as folloing
Sl. No. Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005
1 Age ,experience and education not required for Skilled , Sami skilled Un skilled work men to work
on AN-32 defense a/c 1800 hrs. servicing
2 Unlawful Recruitment of technical (ITI) / fresh fresh diploma holders, diploma holder(EXM),
Workmen at Hal Agra in year 1998 , 1999, 2002-03 , 2003-04 , 2006-07 ,more than 80 percent
are untrained / unqualified without any course like MCF AN-32 / on job training , are doing 1800hrs
servicing of AN- 32, which is flight safety hazards And Life of Pilot of IAF on rick.
3 Not only in Hal Agra but in all the divisions of HAL (under corporate office Bangalore,) maximum
technicians & eng. are unqualified and untrained on that particular IAF A/C for 3rd and 4TH line
servicing, repairing, and calibration
] Sl. No. Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005
4 HAL Managers Eng./ technicians illegally drawing HRA as well as holding service accommodations
which is Exposed under RTI act 2005 by me now stopped and recovery being raised of
concerned defaulters since year 2000 to 2011 ,HRA recoverdfrom few Managers Eng./ technicians
but No inquiry / investigation and disciplinar action against them for misusing the government fund
and property. Recovery raised but No inquiry / investigation and disciplinary action (HRA
recovered with interst Still 14 defaulters managers are left )
5 Unlawful Recruitment of none technical. Workmen at Hal Agra in year 2002 ,No Govt
rules of reservation (GEN. / OBC / SC / ST / EXM )/ followed by hal
6 The Time Of Recruitment Promod Vasist s/o U.N Vasist and candidate KK Arala s/o dn
Sharma were over aged
7 Falls.Cast certificate of candidate Amit Malik diploma holder submitted to board
8 Employer Pension Scheme (EPS) details of all Ex. IAF at HAL (D) Agra from 2000 to 2005 Money
not refunded to those Ex IAF who has not completed 10 years of service (on discharge /
termination / service not extended)
9 NOC not obtained from Zela Sainik Board / DGR with Central Govt. approval by HAL while
Recruitment of diploma holders in the year of 2002 , 2004 ,2006 at HAL (D),Agra Vacancies not
published. In News paper nor invited applicants, (malfunctions)
10 Selected candidate. Manish Mandal fresh diploma holder recruited with false date of birth and
he served one and half years at HAL (D),Agra, No Action department Taken Against the M.
Mandel
11 Technical departmental head AN-32, Mr.Omprakash at HAL (D), Agra who assessed the assessment
for the year of 2004-05 was untrained and unqualified MCF AN-32
12 All total ITI / fresh diploma holder / EXM to carried out 1800hrs services on an-32 a/c
Are maximum untrained and unqualified MCF AN-32, which is hazardous to flight safety and
life of pilot
13 Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in PF.,Recovery raised but No investigation / inquiry
and disciplinary action (Approx.Rs.4500000/ )
14 Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in ESI. Recovery raised but No investigation / inquiry
and disciplinary action (Approxrs. Rs 2.8000 / ).
15 Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in income tex in HAL Agra by EXM(24), Recovery raised
but No inquiry investigation and disciplinary action (Approx. Rs 25.00000/)
16 123 A/C of IAF crashed in last 10 years due to untrained HAL technicians and eng. , costing Rs
98 millions, which is loss to IAF / Govt / Public money (Rs 98 millions, to be recovered from HAL
Note- Documantry proof of all exposed corruption are with under signed
The Period-2000-2012
4.CIC imposed penalty of Rs. 25000 / Warning / Show cause notice issued to Corrupt and negligent HAL
management HALTAD Kanpur and luck now
5. There for it is requested to look into the following points and inquiry investigation and disciplinary
action against chairmen HAL in national interest-
1.Unlawful and illegal Recruitment of technical (ITI) / fresh fresh diploma holders, diploma
holders (EXM),Workmen at Hal Agra in year 1998 , 1999, 2002-03 , 2003-04 , 2006-07, to be
Treated as cancelled and action to be taken against back hander boards because Govt rules of
reservation (GEN. / OBC / SC / ST / EXM ), NOC not obtained from Zela Sainik Board / DGR with
Central Govt. No notification given to any news paper which is Flight Safety Hazards, National
Security Hazards And Life of Pilot of IAF on risk.
Proof of illegal Recruitment at Hal Agra in year 1998 , 1999, 2002-03 , 2003-04 , 2006-07,
A -Color blind / low vision- Raj Veer Singh – ITI – 1998-99
B.- Color blind / low vision – Mukesh Kumar-Fresh Diploma -2002 -04
C.- Submitted falls DOB certificate Manish Mandle- Fresh Diploma -2002–04
D.- Submitted falls Cast certificate(Kumhar) Amit Malik (Jat)- Fresh Diploma -2002–04
E.-Over age KK Arala Non Tech. 2002—04
Promod Vashit- Non Tech . 2002—04
F.- Submitted falls certificate of OBC Sudhakar(Brahamin) Ex-IAF -2002—04
G.-Medically Unfit psycho patient RN Pandey Ex-IAF- 2006
Recruitment Board became blind ?, Board was back hander?
2 .Appx.80 to 90 percent Eng. And Technicians are not Aeronautical Eng .And Diploma, doing 1800.Hrs
servicing of AN-32 A/C of IAFat HAL base Agra. Also same condition in all division of HAL ,Which i
is exposed under RTI act 2005. So
MRO from HAL of defense A/C to be stopped with Immediate effect to save the life of
pilots of IAF and national wealth
3. .HAL Managers illegally drawing HRA as well as holding service accommodation which is Exposed
under RTI act 2005 by me now stopped and recovery being raised of concerned defaulters since
year 2000 to 2012 ,No inquiry / No investigation and disciplinary action taken against them for
misusing the government fund and property. They can harm the nation, involved in anti nation
activity to be taken on task, no one is authorized to develop them self at the cast of nation ,
No investigation and disciplinary action taken against them for misusing the
government fund and property?
4. .Falls Cast certificate of Selected candidate. Amit Malik diploma holder submitted SC / ST Cast
certificate(kumbhar)) to board being JAT by cast, Exposed under RTI act 2005, no action/
No investigation and disciplinary action taken against?
5 Selected candidates. Manish Mandal fresh diploma holder recruited submitted with false date of birth
and he served one and half years at HAL (D),Agra, Exposed but negligent &currepted HAL
department not taken any action because board was back handers to be taken on task,
No investigation and disciplinary action taken against him?
6. . Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in PF at HAL Agra,
No Action taken against Negligent & defaulter HAL TAD Kanpur management?
7. Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in ESI, at HAL Agra, action to be taken against Negligent &
defaulter HAL TAD Kanpur management
No Action taken against Negligent & defaulter HAL TAD Kanpur management?
8 Corruption exposed under RTI act 2005 in income tax at HAL Agra by 24 EXM, action to be taken
Against defaulter EXM & HAL Negligent management they found involved in anti national activity
Govt. giving them smart pension from IAF and smart pay from HAL still not faithful to nation by not
giving the income tax( by concealed the pension) to nation , can do any harm to nation for money there
for their pension should be stopped and serious action to be taken against them.
No Action taken against EXM, for conceal the pension and not paying the income tax
9 123 A/C of IAF crashed due to untrained Technicians and eng. Of HAL. , Costing Rs 98 millions
which is loss to IAF / Govt / Public money to be recovered from negligent HAL MOD management
and deposit in national treasury./ IAF
5. Including Top brass like OIC / ED in HAL are exposed under rti act 2005 most corrupted, misusing
the govt fund and property, not paying the tax to Govt. etc exposed under RTIAct 2005, like RC
Sharma ED ,Gp. Capt Navneet Sharma OIC HAL Agra,includindg so many eng., Technician ,
managers
Negligent and corrupt HAL management HR, GM, MD, PIO/ CPIO / AA are found most Corrupted
supporting the corruptions misleading to Hon President of India Sh. APJ Abdul Kalam ,Smt Pritibha
Patil , Parnav Mukher ji , Secretary to the gov. Of India, defense ,Sec to DDDP (HAL ) MOD , Defance
Minister Parnav Mukher ji/ , Sh. AK Antony, Exposed under RTI Act 2005 Negligent and corrupt
HAL management HR, GM, MD, PIO/ CPIO / AA are found involved in Corruptions in PF, ESI,
Income Tax Etc, Exposed under RTI Act 2005
Loss of 123 a/c of Indian air force /National wealth and precious life of pilots, costing of Rs. 98 millions ,which is public money must be recoverd from department of defence production (HAL) MOD and given to IAF .All damocrates and buricrates(public servents) held responsible and accountable for this loss of Indian air force / Nation / Public Money
AFTER RECOVERY
Indian air force will be one of the Best and strongest Air Force in whole world
Poor servicing of an-32 A/C by untrained / unqualified technicians / eng. at HAL Agra / IN ALL HAL DIVI., Corrupt & Negligent Management, Poor maintenance of IAF A/C, Not quality conscious
Matter of corruption I am reporting since Jan. 2005 to till date
GM hal Kanpur
MD hal Lucknow
Chairman Hal banglore Burocrates / Public servants
Secretary Deptt, of defence production hal
Secretary to the gov. Of India, defence Democrates / Public servants
Defence minister
Hon. President of India
But, so far no action or investigation ordered from deptt. /ministry / hon.president of India After loss of Rs. 98 millions of public
Waiting for more loss
Collection of evidences against HAL MOD and report UNDER RTI ACT 2005
CORRUPTIONS IN HAL EXPOSED UNDER RTI ACT 2005 BY
TAJPAL YADAV,Ex-IAF & RTI ACTIVIST
Poor servicing of an-32 A/C by untrained / unqualified technicians / eng. at HAL Agra / IN ALL HAL DIVI., Corrupt & Negligent Management, Poor maintenance of IAF A/C, Not quality conscious
Sl. No. Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005
1. Age ,experience and education not required for Skilled , Sami skilled Un skilled work
men to work on AN-32 defense a/c 1800 hrs. servicing
2. Unlawful Recruitment of technical (ITI) / fresh fresh diploma holders, diplomaholders
(EXM),Workmen at Hal Agra in year 1998 , 1999, 2002-03 , 2003-04 , 2006-07 ,more
than 80 percent are untrained / unqualified without any course like MCF AN-32 / on job
training , are doing 1800hrs servicing of AN- 32, which is flight safety hazards And Life
of Pilot of IAF on rick.
3. Not only in Hal Agra but in all the divisions of HAL (under corporate office Bangalore,)
maximum technicians & eng. are unqualified and untrained on that particular IAF A/C
for 3rd and 4TH line servicing, repairing, and calibration
4 HAL Managers illegally drawing HRA as well as holding service accommodations
which is Exposed under RTI act 2005 by me now stopped and recovery being raised of
concerned defaulters since year 2000 to 2011 ,No inquiry / investigation and disciplinary
action against them for misusing the government fund and property
]
5. Unlawful Recruitment of none technical. Workmen at Hal Agra in year 2002 ,No Govt
rules ofreservation (GEN. / OBC / SC / ST / EXM )/
6. Education, experience and age of all candidate including Promod Vasist s/o U.N Vasist
and candidate KK Arala s/o dn Sharma At The Time Of Recruitment
7. .Cast certificate of all candidate/ OBC / SC / ST including Amit Malik diploma holder
submitted to board
8 .Employer Pension Scheme (EPS) details of all Ex. IAF at HAL (D) Agra from 2000 to
2005 Money not refunded to those Ex IAF who has not completed 10 years of service
(on discharge / termination / service not extended)
9 NOC not obtained from Zela Sainik Board / DGR with Central Govt. approval by HAL
while Recruitment of diploma holders in the year of 2002 , 2004 ,2006 at HAL (D),
Agra Vacancies not published. In News paper nor invited applicants, (malfunctions)
10 Selected candidate. Manish Mandal fresh diploma holder recruited with false date
of birth and he served one and half years at HAL (D),Agra,No Action
department TakenAgainst , the Manish Mandel
Sl. No. Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005
11 Technical departmental head mr.omprakash at HAL (D), Agra who assessed the
assessment for the year of 2004-05 was untrained and unqualified MCF AN-32
12 All total 85 to 90 ITI / fresh diploma holder EXM to carried out 1800hrs services on an-32
a/c , were maximum untrained and unqualifiedMCF AN-32 ,which is hazardous to flight
safety and life of pilot
13 Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005 in PF
14 Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005 in ESI
15 Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005 in income tex in HAL Agra by EXM
16
17 123 A/C of IAF crashed due to untrained Technicians and eng. , costing Rs 98 millions
which is loss to IAF / Govt / Public money
Matter of corruption
In indian air force technicians &Eng.trained in CTI , E & ITI Banglore minimum 80 percent passing marks AGAIN under gone for MCF on that perticuler A/C at TATRA AF Stn. Barakpur
1. Loss of 123 a/c of Indian air force /National wealth and precious life of pilots, costing of
Rs. 98 millions ,which is public money must be recoverd from depaetment of defance
production (HAL) MOD and given to IAF,which is public money
2. Eng. / technicians not to be permit for MRO(Maintain,Repair ,O/H) defance A/C of indian Army,indian Navy Indian Air Force ,with out –
A.- Deg. In aeronautical Eng. minimum 80 percent passing marks A/C Eng.
B- Diploma In aeronautical Eng minimum 80 percent passing marks for A/C technician
B.- MCF on that perticuler defance A/C from TATRA AF Stn. Barrakpur minimum 60
percent passing marks
C –On job traing minimum 60 percent passing marks
Deg. Diploma In aeronautical Eng, MCF and on job traing then only eng. And technicians are authorised to work on a/c
All divi. In HAL technicians & eng. Not trained in such technical institute like in CTIAF , E & ITI AF Banglore , No minimum percent passing marks, No MCF is required,
Minimum qualification for technicians & eng.in HAL to do MRO of defance A/C is simply ITI, Diploma and EXM
It is exposed under RTI act 2005
So HAL Dept. of deffence production MOD is hazardious for
Air Wothiness, Flight Safity and Defance
We demand
1. Must An Air Marshal to Head HAL
2. Unlawful and illigal Recruitment of technical (ITI) / fresh fresh diploma holders, diploma
holders(EXM),Workmen at Hal Agra in year 1998 , 1999, 2002-03 , 2003-04 , 2006-07 ,
to be treated as cancelled and action to be taken against back hander boards because Govt
rules of reservation (GEN. / OBC / SC / ST / EXM ), NOC not obtained from Zela Sainik
Board / DGR with Central Govt. No notification given to any news paper which is flight safety
hazards national security hazards And Life of Pilot of IAF on risk. to be treated as cancelled,
and action to be taken against back hander boards which is Flight Safety Hazards , National
Security Hazards And Life of Pilot of IAF on risk. Exposed under RTI act 2005
3. Appx.80 to 90 percent Eng. And Technicians are not Aeronautcal Eng.And Diploma doing
1800.Hrs servicing of AN-32 A/C of IAFat HAL base Agra. Also same condition in all division
of HAL ,Which is exposed under RTI act 2005. So MRO from HAL of defance A/C to be
stopped with immidiate effact to save the life of pilotsof IAF and national wealth
4. HAL Managers illegally drawing HRA as well as holding service acomodation which is
Exposed under RTI act 2005 by me now stopped and recovery being raised of concerned
defaulters since year 2000 to 2012 ,No inquiry / No investigation and disciplinary action
taken against them for misusing the government fund and property. Thay can harm the
nation,involved in anti nation activity to be taken on task,no one is authorised to dovlop
themself at the cast of nation,should be behind the bar
5. .Falls Cast certificate of Selected candidate. Amit Malik diploma holder submitted SC / ST
Cast certificate(badhai) to board being JAT by cast, Exposed under RTI act 2005
6 Selected candidates. Manish Mandal fresh diploma holder recruited submitted with false date
of birth and he served one and half years at HAL (D),Agra, Exposed but negligent &currepted
HAL department not taken any action because board was back handers to be taken on task,
7. All aeronautical trained MCF technician/ eng.from indian air force to be re-employed in HAL
for better quality concius and save the precius life of IAFpilots ad national wealth
8. Curreption exposed under RTI act 2005 in PF at HAL Agra, action to be taken against
Negligent & defaulter HAL TAD Kanpur managment
9. Correption exposed under RTI act 2005 in ESI, at HAL Agra, action to be taken against
Negligent & defaulter HAL TAD Kanpur managment
10. Correption exposed under RTI act 2005 in income tex in HAL Agra by EXM, action to be taken
Against defaulter EXM &HAL Negligent management thay found involved in anti national
activity ,Govt. giving them smart pension from IAF and smart pay from HAL still not faithfull to
nation by not giving the income tex to nation CAN do any harm to nation for money their for
their pension should be stopped and serius action to be taken against them.
11 Exposed under RTI act 2005 123 A/C of IAF crashed due to untrained Technicians and engof
HAL. , Costing Rs 98 millions which is loss to IAF / Govt / Public money to be recoverd
from negligent HAL MOD mangment and deposit in national tressury.
12 HAL must take All trained and experianced tecnicians and Eng.from replacement cell of Air HQ
subroto pak New Delhi,they are diploma / deg. In aeronautical eng.with 80 percent passing
marks plus MCFAND 20 years experianceon a/c in IAF
14 HAL must take all clerk, accounts, and security staff from replacement cell of Air HQ
subroto park New Delhi, they are more disciplined more faithfull to the nation then
civilians
A. Manager’s eng. technicians including top brass like ED in HAL are found most correpted like
Back Handers during recruitment, misusing the govt fund and property, not paying the tex to
Govt. etc exposed under RTIAct 2005
B. Negligent and corrupt HAL management HR, GM, MD, PIO/ CPIO / AA are found most
Correpted suporting the correptios misleading the hon president of India, sec. to govt of India
(Defance), u/s to department of defance production (HAL) , Exposed under RTIAct 2005
C Negligent and corrupt HAL management HR, GM, MD, PIO/ CPIO / AA are found involved in
Correptios in PF, ESI, Income Tax Etc, Exposed under RTIAct 2005
Public is above public servents (Beurocrates and Damocrates)
in republic of Bharat, Govt. of Bharat)
…………..and nation is above the public of nation……………..….
Corruptions exposed by me under RTI act 2005
Published in print media
With documantry proof
I introduce myself as a/c technician (Ex- Sgt) MCF trained on AN-32 Canabra ,of MI-8 &MI-17 & 20 years experience in air force as a/c technician. Minimum passing marks in IAF after completing training which is equal to diploma in aeronautics egg. minimum passing marks are 80 percent, then we go to under MCF (maintenance conversion flight -Six month curse) on that particular a/c, minimum passing marks are 6o percent then we go for OJT (three month course) under supervisor. Then in IAF we are authorized to work on a/c, and other so many tech.coureses to clear 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th line service of a/c
Where as in Hal they take fresh ITI, fresh diploma , and Hal do not trained them for such technical a/c training to work on IAF a/c. In Hal maximum technical head are simply deg.or diploma, not in aeronautical egg ,80 to 90 percent in Hal, technician / eggs are unqualified and untrained to work on that particulate IAF a/c, where are they in Hal, I exposed that in Hal Agra,/ All hal divi. more then 90 percent technician / eng. Are UN trained and UN qualified MCF AN-32 / SU 30 / JAGUAR Etc / 3rd and 4th line servicing on How they are doing 1800 hrs servicing of an-32 since year 2000 TIL Date I got all documentary proof against technical corruption in Hal Under RTI act 2005,I am reporting the matter that poor servicing of defense a/c by Hal, since 10 mar.2005 Hal authority / IAF authority / MOD / hon. president of India for that Hal victimized me to raise the voice Against poor service of defense a/c ,no investigation from MOD / president of India till date
More then 1000 fighter a/c of IAF crashed and about 700 pilots killed due to poor mro by untrained unqualified technicians / eng. In halLoss of precious life of pilots of Indian air force and heavy loss of national wealth millions of mioopns to iaf / govt / public money, hal dept. Of defance production, mod is accountable It is not just surprising but shocking that India has lost 1010 fighter aircrafts since 1971-72 in crashes alone – not only are we losing precious lives but also country’s wealth and it is time to get up and raise our voice.
-Hal is hidden enemy of nation / -HAL killed enough pilots of A/C crashed of IAF,
cost beyond imagination / – HAL burring the country’s wealth cannot be
recovered / – So HAL is curse for nation
IAF Pilot mistake / Human error Nil Because of
The Aircraft & Systems Testing Establishment (ASTE) is a unit of the Indian Air Force (IAF) that evaluates aircraft and systems for induction into user organizations. Most new aircraft types and major airborne systems must have ASTE’s stamp of approval to be considered fit for service in India. While many countries have testing facilities of one kind or the other, training of flight test personnel is not often imparted in them. ASTE’s Air Force Test Pilots School (AFTPS) is only the fifth such institution in the world. The combination of flight testing and training makes ASTE the Indian Air Force’s mini-Edward’s Air Force Base (USA) or Boscombe Down (UK). And, it is just as professional.[1]
Directive was given to the HAL, to strictly follow IAF’s instructions on maintenance of the aircraft. Poor industrial maintenance is also a problem. In November 2011, India’s first astronaut, Rakesh Sharma, who also has much experience as a test pilot with Hindustan Aeronautics limited, blamed faulty planning in public defense companies (known in India as public sector undertakings, or PSUs) for the high rate of crashes, indicating that “the PSUs have the infrastructure but they do not have the expertise.” Sharma said that he would send back fighter planes to the laboratories if he detected defective parts but that he soon found out that instead of doing research and development on these parts, the laboratories fitted them in other fighter plane
AHMEDABAD: First Indian astronaut Rakesh Sharma on Sunday blamed faulty planning in defence public sector units for MIG crashes. He was speaking at the annual confluence of Indian Institute of Management-Ahmadabad. PSUs like Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) and Defence Research and Development Organisation ( DRDO) are being run like political and bureaucratic fiefdom, said Sharma. “The PSUs have the infrastructure but they do not have the expertise,” he said. He proposed public-private partnership (PPP)
November 28, 2011 | TNN AHMEDABADAHMEDABAD: Improper and unrealistic planning for execution of defense PSUs lead to MIG aircraft crashing in the country. Public sector undertakings (PSUs) like Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) and Defense Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) in the country are being run like political and bureaucratic fiefdom. These strong views were expressed by the first Indian astronaut Rakesh Sharma . Sharma was giving a speech at the Indian Institute of Management-Ahmadabad (IIM-)
In 1947 one rupee = one dollar
In 2012 Rs. 50 = one dollar, where is diff.money ?
how to recover this loss of national wealth?
Nation should know what is HAL? Unqualified technicians, Negligent
Management, Poor maintenance of IAF A/C, Not quality conscious
Since, HAL was responsible for servicing and maintenance of the aircraft and loss occurred due to negligence of its technician during routine maintenance check of aircraft, the amount of loss should be recovered from HAL instead of regularising it. Government should look into the matter and explore the possibility of concluding agreement with HAL clearly specifying the responsibilities and accountability.Accepting the facts, the Ministry stated, in December 2000, that Air HQ have been advised to recover the amount from HAL instead of regularising it, as the loss has occurred due to negligence of HAL. They added that Air HQ have been advised to explore the possibility of concluding an agreement with HAL specifying their responsibilities and accountabilit
There for It is requested for an in-depth investigation /action against chairmen Hal corporate office 15/1 cubon road Bangalore department of defense production (MOD) for Negligent & Corrupt Management, Poor maintenance of IAF A/C, Not quality conscious, developing themselves at the cast of nation
TAJPAL YADAV,
Ex-IAF (Aeronautical Eng & RTI Activist
Maritorius Madle, MOD / Best RTI Award 2009
Protecter of freedom of nation Hon. 26.JAN 2012
Sawtenetrta ka sarthi Hon.15.Aug.2012/Social worker / Social Eng.
121, PUSHPANJLI NAGAR ,PH. -3 , SHAHGANJ AGRA UP BHARAT
Dear Readers,
If Shri. Sameer Kumar Khare, Joint Secretary (Estt.) and Public Grievances & CVO was honest CVO that menace he was take action against Dr A K Tyagi, CPIO, DRDO Hqrs Scientist’F’, DRDO, Ministry of Defence, New Delhi (Reference Dr.Arun Kumar Case).
Thank you.