Today I have received RTI reply from PMO, South block, New Delhi in respect of my online RTI request in respect of PMO website regarding Interact with Honorable Prime Minister of India. It is observed that when citizen of India submitted some feedback, suggestions to improve system or information regarding misuse of fund & power by authorities, PMO officials are taking these inputs as personal grievances of individuals rather than taking inputs in national interest. The PMO officials forwarding that information directly send to concern organizations without concealing the name of individuals, it may be affect the carrier of individual or authorities can target to harass the individual.
It is requested please submit your valuable comments and suggestion on subject matter and regarding handling of RTI’s.
Subject: Corruption Complaints Status against Dr A K Saxena, Director, DMSRDE,DRDO, Kanpur & other officials working with him (Complaints during period from 29/11/2013 to 11/06/2014)
Sir,
Please find enclosed Corruption Complaints Status against Dr A K Saxena, Director, DMSRDE, DRDO, Kanpur & other officials working with him (Complaints during period from 29/11/2013 to 15/01/2014).
All complaints sent to CVC with documentary evidences till date no action was taken by DRDO hqrs because Ex Secretary, DRD, SA to RM, DG, DRDO Sh Avinash Chander patronized Dr A K Saxena, Director, DMSRDE.
DRDO hqrs constituted two fact finding committees to investigate the complaints. First fact finding committee under chairmanship of Dr S S Negi, Sc ‘H’ only grope the complaints and smell only the hands of Sh Navin Prakash Gupta, Sc ‘C’ and Sh R P Bhatt, Sc ‘F’. Rest real findings buried under the Sh Avinash chander’s table because that time Dr S S Negi was in the race of IRDE Lab directorship.
Based on his unconstitutional (because the fact finding committee jurisdiction is only find the facts and handover those facts to competent authority not to give any suggestions) suggestions DRDO hqrs transferred both scientists from DMSRDE, Kanpur and gave hurdle free play ground to Dr A K Saxena’s team to collect as much run (Gandhi) from the unrequited, low specifications items/ machineries etc from unqualified vendors. (Dr A K Singh, DOP submitted an affidavit in Allahabad court that on the basis of first fact finding committee’s suggestions DRDO transferred Sh Navin Prakash Gupta, Sc ‘C’ to DRL, Tezpur)
The copy emails are a security threat waning in the concern of defence preparedness as these emails exposes that vendors are know the all future plans of DRDO R&D that what they are planning to develop and what are their aim & objects. But unfortunately our responsible post holders are ignoring such activities of their beloved ones.
Second fact finding committee under chairmanship of Dr D.C. Pande, Sc’H’ , LRDE, Bangalore visited DMSRDE and grilled Dr A K Saxena’s team but delayed the report waited up to result of Distinguished Scientist. Unfortunately Dr D.C. Pande not able to achieved goal, submitted report. In the mean time Sh Avinash Chander hold his position very strongly and showed his lousy power by making Ms Tessy Thomas as Director, ASL and her husband Cmdr S K Patel director QRS with violation of all rules regulation, with this success he kicked the second fact finding report proudly in to dustbin.
It is requested that it is high time top show DRDO’s corrupt scientists that you are paid for science and development not for making fun ride with vendors. ( like Director, GTRE, Mohan Rao who caught by Karnataka police in massage parlor with Israeli company rep) The technology is so powerful that now 250 crores eyes are watching corrupt official’s each and every move.
The following table will show you clear picture of handling corruption complaints related to DRDO. The massage is to all corrupt officials is that nothing will happen to anyone so enjoy life with corrupt practices.
Your early needful action in this matter required. The all honest DRDO officials are waiting the decision so they can feel the difference of new fare governance.
Regards
Prabhu Dandriyal, 21-Sunderwala, Raipur,
Dehradun-248008
Phone 0135- 2787750, Mobile- 9411114879,
e-mail id prabhudoon@gmail.com website www.corruptionindrdo.com
Corruption Complaints Status against Dr A K Saxena, Director, DMSRDE, DRDO, Kanpur & other officials working with himCorruption Complaints Status against Dr A K Saxena, Director, DMSRDE, DRDO, Kanpur & other officials working with him (Complaints during period from 29/11/2013 to 11/06/2014)
To, 28th February 2015 Dr. RB Sharma, CPIO, DRDO HQ, Min. of Defence, DRDO Bhawan, Rajaji Marg, New Delhi-110011
Hello,
Kindly provide me with the following information requested under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in respect of misusing of Government vehicles by Dr M R Bhutiyani Director, Defence Terrain Research Laboratory (DTRL), Delhi. It is observed that since last month Dr M R Bhutiyani, Director, DTRL, DRDO continuously misusing the three officials vehicles of DTRL for his daughter marriage program. Today (28th Feb 2015) morning around 7:45 AM he used staff car for his family & relative. I would like to appreciate Sh Sunil Dhar, Sc F and Col Harsh for not cooperating Dr M R Bhutiyani, Director, DTRL, for manipulations in official car/ vehicles log books.
Provide the logbook details of DTRL officials vehicles form 01/02/2015 to 28/02/2015.
Provide the name of officials who demanded the DTRL officials vehicles form 01/02/2015 to 28/02/2015
Provide the overtime details of drivers of DTRL officials vehicles form 01/02/2015 to 28/02/2015
If vehicles were driven by army service personal then total hours of his duty from the gate record of Metcalf house from 01/02/2015 to 28/02/2015
Total number of requisition for personal use of official vehicle by Dr MR Bhutiyani, Sc G, Director, DTRL
Note matter is related to corruption allegation and for proof the photograph is enclosed of DTRL vehicle where Saturday 21st Feb 2015 the Army jawan doing duty since morning, ferrying Tandoor, Karahis (Halwai Utensils) for Dr MR Bhutiyani, Sc G, Director, DTRL, DRDO daughter marriage
To 27TH February 2015
Sh Satpal Chauhan
Joint Secretary (Admn), CPIO
Room No.194, North Block,
New Delhi -110 001
Hello,
kindly provide me with the following information requested under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in respect of provision of categorized security to VVIPs/VIPs, other high dignitaries and individuals. Security is provided on the basis of comprehensive assessment of threat by the security agencies. There is a system of periodical review of the security provided to persons on the basis of threat inputs received from time to time. It is observed that Ms Tessy Thomas, Scientist H of DRDO, Hyderabad availing police security for last six years. It is very astonishing fact that she is the single case of DRDO in which individual getting such VIP treat without having any such achievement which can quote in international level. It is purely eye wash or politically motivated move of DRDO management. It is heard that Ms Tessy Thomas visiting Kuwait in next month participating some religious function.
Provide the copy of request of Ms Tessy Thomas for police security from MHA.
The exact date security provided to Ms Tessy Thomas by MHA
How many times MHA periodical reviews the security allotment of Ms Tessy Thomas, whether they reported and recommended on the basis of threat inputs or simply continue the allotment without any review.
Six year back she was mere Scientist F, that time there was more than 1000 Scientists F working in the organization. Provide the type of threat, is that individual’s family problem, is that communal angle, and is that scientific knowledge asset security.
Provide the role of DRDO for recommending her for security necessity. The name of DRDO official who recommended to MHA.
The case was approved by Sh A K Antony (Yes/No)
The total amount spends on security of Ms Tessy Thomas by MHA or State government till date.
Whether Ms Tessy Thomas get clearance from MHA for her Kuwait visit(Yes/No)
To 27TH February 2015
Shri Biplab Kumar Roy,
Under Secretary (Admn) , CPIO,
Room No. 225-E, North Block,
New Delhi – 110001
Hello,
kindly provide me with the following information requested under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in respect of issues of special concurrence of Ministry of finance/Deptt of expenditure in exemption of extant ban vide their ID Note No. No 18(2) /E.Coord)/ 2013 (84982) dated 28/05/213).
DRDO requested exemption on purchasing of vehicles total cost of Rs 2.23,00,000 (Two crore twenty three lakh only) against project Rustom -II and Phase – I development of Aeronautical Test Range (ATR). ADE. DRDO purchased 4(Four) Toyota Innova in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle (RVT) and practically using those vehicle as Staff cars. (Picture of vehicles using as staff car and all details enclosed for your ready reference.)
Copy of DRDO request for exemption on purchasing of vehicles against project Rustom -II and Phase – I development of Aeronautical Test Range (ATR). ADE
Copy of special concurrence of Ministry of finance/Deptt. of expenditure against DRDO request for above said project.
माननीयश्रीनरेंद्रमोदीजीदिनाक 27फरवरी 2015प्रधानमंत्री, भारत सरकारकक्षसंख्या 152 पीएमओसाउथब्लाकनईदिल्ली -110011
विषय : डीआरडीओ के वैज्ञानिकों द्वारा सरकार के नियमो को धता बता कर प्रोजेक्ट्स के नाम पर तकनीकी शब्दावली का प्रयोग कर महंगी गाड़िया खरीद कर उनका निजी उपयोग कर रहे है।
आदरणीय मोदी जी
यह बहुत ही खेद का विषय है की जिन डीआरडीओ के वैज्ञानिकों की तुलना आपने 20 अगस्त 2014 को पुरस्कार वितरण करते हुए ऋषि मुनियो से की थी उनमे सबसे सीनियर डायरेक्टर जनरल, ऐरो, डॉ के तमिलमणि द्वारा सरकार के सारे नियमो का मजाक बनाते हुए प्रोजेक्ट की गाड़ी का न केवल दुर्प्रयोग कर रहे अपितु औरो को भी गाड़ियों के दुर्पयोग के लिए सहयोग कर रहे है।
डीआरडीओ के संस्थान ए डी इ, बैंगलोर में प्रोजेक्ट रुस्तम – 2 के अंतरगर्त एक संस्वीकृति संख्या DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D दिनाक 23/02/2011 द्वारा 5 गाड़ियां रिमोट वीडियो टर्मिनल (आर वी टी) (टोयटा इन्नोवा समतुल्य) 77 लाख में खरीदने की स्वीकृति प्रदान की गयी। (सैंक्शन डिटेल संलग्न है)
एक इन्नोवा डायरेक्टर जनरल, ऐरो, डॉ के तमिलमणि द्वारा इस्तेमाल की जा रही है। गाड़ी में डीजी ऐरो का बोर्ड लगा है। ड्राइवर आर्मी का एक हवालदार नियुक्त है। गाड़ी को देख कर कोई नहीं कह सकता की गाड़ी का इस्तेमाल प्रोजेक्ट रुस्तम – 2 में रिमोट वीडियो टर्मिनल (आर वी टी) में हो रहा है। (चित्र संलग्न है )
डॉ के तमिलमणि द्वारा भारत सरकार के नियम विरुद्ध ट्रांसपोर्ट अलाउंस लाभ भी लिया जा रहा है। (जनवरी की सैलरी स्लिप संलग्न है)
डॉ के तमिलमणि को सरकार ने सेकंड सेवा विस्तार 62-64 वर्ष भी दिया है जोकि मई 2016 तक है। परन्तु केवल भगवान ही जानता है कि डॉ तमिलमणि द्वारा देश व् डीआरडीओ को क्या प्रदान किया है। क्योंकि देश की साइंटिफिक क्षेत्र में उनके योगदान का कोई चिन्ह नजर नहीं आता है केवल डीआरडीओ के स्वयं प्रयोजित पुरस्कार ही उनके खाते में हैं जिनकी कंही भी मान्यता नहीं है। डॉक्ट्रेट की उपाधि का भी अभी अभी प्रबंध किया।
रिमोट वीडियो टर्मिनल (आर वी टी) नाम से ली गयी दूसरी गाड़ी एडीइ निदेशक द्वारा तथा तीसरी गाड़ी प्रोजेक्ट डायरेक्टर रुस्तम -२ द्वारा और सूत्रों के अनुसार बाकि की दो गाड़ियों का कोई सुराग नहीं है।
इसी प्रकार से डीआरडीओ के पुणे स्थित संस्थान एच इ एम आर एल के निदेशक श्री विकास भट्टाचार्य द्वारा भी इसी प्रकार से एक इन्नोवा मोबाइल इन्ट्रूमेंट कैरियर नाम से खरीद कर अपने इस्तेमाल में ली जा रही है। टेंडर, फर्म्स, गाड़ी का लाल बत्ती लगा चित्र, सप्लाई आर्डर संख्या आदि संलग्न है।
इन उपरोक्त तथ्यों से यह लगता है कि रक्षा लेखा विभाग का जैसे डीआरडीओ के अधिकारीयों द्वारा अपहरण कर दिया है। क्या उन्हे वार्षिक ऑडिट में यह सब दिखाई नहीं देता या रक्षा लेखा अधिकारियो ने आँख बंद कर रखी है ?
आपसे अनुरोध है की आपकी लाल किले की प्रतिज्ञा “न खायंगे न खाने देंगे” का कुछ तो असर इन तथाकित डीआरडीओ के वैज्ञानिकों पर डालने की कृपा करे अन्यथा ये इस देश के करदाताओं से मिले बहुमूल्य पैसो को अपने मजे के लिए उड़ा देंगे।
आपसे यह भी अनुरोध है कि संलग्न शिकायती पत्र को सीवीसी व् सीविओ (रक्षा मंत्रालय) को तत्काल प्रभाव से जाँच करने के आदेश के साथ अग्रसारित करने का कष्ट करें।
डॉ के तमिलमणि द्वारा इस्तेमाल की जा रही रिमोट वीडियो टर्मिनल (आर वी टी) का चित्र
डॉ के तमिलमणि की जनवरी की सैलरी स्लिप की प्रतिलिपि
एच इ एम आर एल के निदेशक श्री विकास भट्टाचार्य द्वारा इस्तेमाल की जा रही इन्नोवा मोबाइल इन्ट्रूमेंट कैरियर का चित्र
मोबाइल इन्ट्रूमेंट कैरियर की टेंडर, फर्म्स, व् अन्य डिटेल्स
To 27th February 2015
Chief Vigilance Commissioner,
Central Vigilance Commission,
Satarkata Bhawan, A Block, GPO Complex, INA,
New Delhi – 110004
To
The Joint Secretary (Estt.) and Public Grievances & CVO,
Ministry of Defence, of India,
97, South Block,
New Delhi -110 105.
Subject: Complaint regarding misuse of Government funds fooling the country & government by using technical gimmicks.
Sir,
K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore using Toyota Innova vehicle bearing No 14B 113597Y, it seems that vehicle procured under sanction of Project Rustom –II in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle.
According the sanction letter No DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D date 23/02/2011. The 5 no of Toyota Innova sanction for Rs 77 Lakhs in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle was sanctioned as per file No DHRD/76682/ ADE(Proj)(Misc) /VEH/ C /P/01dated 27 June 2013
The letter no DHRD/76682/ADE/(Proj)(Misc)/VEH/P/01 date 27 Jun 2013 signed by Dr Hina A Gokhle, Director, HRD, DRDO Hqrs in its para 4 “This letter issue with special concurrence of Ministry of Finance/Deptt of Expenditure in exemption of the extent ban vide their ID Note No 18(2)/E.Coord)/2013(84982) dated 28/05/213)”. It is clear evidence that DRDO senior scientists try to fooling country system. They are taking extraordinary sanction of vehicle by showing its utility in project by putting name “Remote Video Terminal Vehicle”. The vehicle simply using by Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), as luxury staff car.
At the same time Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore availing the transport allowance of Rs 14490/- which attracts severe disciplinary action against under CCS (CCA) Rules 1965, False claims on the Government like T.A claims reimbursement claims, etc. False claims on the Government like T.A claims reimbursement claims, etc, Obtaining or attempting to obtain any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage without consideration or for a consideration which is not adequate. (Salary slip of month of January 2015 enclosed)
Three vehicles are using by Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), Director, ADE & Program Director Rustom – II, and rest not traceable.
K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore violated the Motor Vehicle Act by putting DG Name plate in front of Toyota Innova.
It is requested that please register case against Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore for maneuvering of Government funds under the provision of prevention of corruption act section 13(2), or any other applicable acts of GOI.
As per DRDO TRANSPORT POLICY- CUM – PROCEDURE 1998
PROCUREMENT OF VEHICLES
4.2 The requirement of vehicles from the procurement point of view, fall under the following three broad categories:-
(a) Service Pattern Vehicles.
(b) Trade Pattern Vehicles.
(c) Specialist / Dedicated Vehicles.
4.8 PRQCUEMENT OF Specialist / Dedicated Vehicles:
The procedure for procurement of the basic vehicle i.e. chassis and engines will be the same as for the Service Pattern/Trade Vehicles i.e, from Army Sources, DGS&E) rate contract or Trade. Modifications/ fabrications base vehicles will be based on the guidelines laid dawn in CWR. These modifications, if cannot be under taken by the selected suppliers / manufacturers will be assigned, under a development / fabrication contract following the DRDO procedures in vogue for such contracts. The expenditure involved will be met from the project for whichsuch vehicles are required.
Toyota Innova 14B 113597Y with name plate DG, Aero
Sanction Details No DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D date 23/02/2011
Salary slip January 2015 of Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero)
The vehicle was procured for Project Rustom in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle. Vide letter No DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D date 23/02/2011.Dr. K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore using Toyota Innova vehicle bearing No 14B 113597Y. The vehicle was procured for Project Rustom -II in the name of Remote Video Terminal VehicleDirector, ADE, Bangalore using Toyota Innova procured for Project Rustom-II in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle
Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore availing the transport allowance Rs 14490. Please see his January pay slip
HEMRL Toyota Innova case
Supply Order No.HEMRL/AT052/D16/LP dt.20.12.2014
Delivery Challan No.SE/11/14-15 dt.31.12.2014
Supply order place to Spar Enterprises Pune
Tender Enquiry place to Spar Enterprises Mumbai
Filel Reference No: HEMRL/MMD/3044/SRP/14-15/249/D-3
Tender Enquiry No.: HEMRL/15ATT097ILP dt.03.11.2014
Tender Opening Date & Time 16-Nov-2014, 1500 hrs
Sh Bikas Bhattacharya, Director, HEMRL, Pune Using this Toyota Innova, The Red beacon is proofToyota Innova DetailsTender InquiryInstrument Mobile Carrier Drawing
Most of Lab Directors/ CC&D/DG etc are using official vehicle not only for themselves but for family members also.
VI th pay commission increased hefty transport allowance, most of these DRDO corrupt officials start managing transport via project vehicle.
Earlier you all witnessed the taxi hiring bills in the tune of Rs 9000 -10000 per week by DLRL scientists,
Please the enclose case of Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore using Toyota Innova vehicle bearing No #14B 113597Y. The Driver is one Army Hawldar, Why army personal because without OT he can use this gentleman, Other reason is he can share the visits of Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), with vendors/suppliers to any ADE employees,
The vehicle was procured for Project Rustom in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle. Vide letter No DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D date 23/02/2011.
मोदी जी आपके हाथो से ईमानदारी की एक वेव भी डॉ के तमिलमणि के अंदर नहीं गयी लगता है तमिलमणि को एक जादू की झप्पी चाहिये
Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore availing the transport allowance Rs 14490. Please see his January payslip.
I have sent all these input to Bangalore based journalist Sh Sharan Poovanna, Senior Correspondent with the New Indian Express. He tried his best to get Dr K Tamilmani’s view but Dr K Tamilmani just walked away without giving any explanation.
Dr K Tamilmani is public servant he cannot escape from responsibility; he is bound to give answer about misusing the poor tax payer’s money.
Today, Dr. K Tamilmani, DG-Aero has come in his own vehicle, but driven by military Havaldar. Interestingly, even ADE office cannot have a military Havaldar posting; Dr. K Tamilmani has managed his posting to ADE and using him as driver.
It is requested and appeal to all DRDO friends just keep your eye open help the government to clean mission.
Jai Hind
.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore using Toyota Innova vehicle bearing No 14B 113597Y. The vehicle was procured for Project Rustom in the name of Remote Video Terminal VehicleThe vehicle was procured for Project Rustom in the name of Remote Video Terminal Vehicle. Vide letter No DRDO/02/333/P/2/Vol-II-394/D/R&D date 23/02/2011.Dr.K Tamilmani, DG (Aero), DRDO, Bangalore availing the transport allowance Rs 14490. Please see his January pay slip
Now Ms Munjula enjoying the post of Director, DARE with blessing of Shri S S Sundaram, Director General, DRDO
To, 22nd February 2015
Dr. RB Sharma, CPIO,
DRDO HQ, Min. of Defence,
DRDO Bhawan, Rajaji Marg,
New Delhi-110011
Hello,
Kindly provide me with the following information requested under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in respect of repeat order placed by Dr. A.K. Saxena, Director , DMSRDE, Kanpur.
As a matter of fact procurement cases under Global/Open/Limited tender takes longer time in finalization and as only few months left for superannuation (31st July 2015) of Dr. A.K. Saxena, thereby he is issuing repeat orders without any requirements of instrument/equipment/material so that cases may be materialised during his tenure.
Information sought –
The number of repeat order placed in financial year 2013-2014 with repeat order justification.
The number of repeat order placed in financial year 2014-2015 with repeat order justification.
Output of item before placing the repeat order i.e. if item is equipment than logbook of uses, if material than product output.
The information is related to corruption not come under schedule –II exemption please finds enclose repeat order examples.
Please see the enclosed photographs of DRTL, Metcalf House DRDO vehicle in front of Prithvi Block of DRDO residential complex, Timarpur.
Today on Saturday 21st Feb 2015 the fouji jawan doing duty since morning, ferrying Tandoor, Karahis (Halwai Utensils ) for Dr MR Bhutiyani, Sc G, Director, DTRL, DRDO daughter marriage. He is so poor that he is getting 14000 Rs Transport Allowances per month. His daughter is software engineer in USA. He is captured directorship by lot of senior scientists. But he is so poor that he is misusing poor tax payers money.
Request all common man that expose all corrupt practices of DRDO officials – Jai Hind
Sh R K Mathur, Defence Secretary, Room No 101 A, South Block, New Delhi – 110011
General Dalbir Singh Suhag, Army Hqrs, Sena Bhawan, Rajaji Marg, New Delhi 110105 – For necessary action please DRDO is using country’s jawan for their personal family business.Date & Time 21/02/15 at 09:11 Hrs Vehicle No 03B/86197XDate & Time 21/02/15 at 09:11 Hrs Vehicle No 03B/86197XDate & Time 21/02/15 at 09:11 Hrs Vehicle No 03B/86197X
To Date–21 February 2015
Shri Syed Ekram Rizwi,
Director & Central Public Information Officer,
Prime Minister’s Office,
South Block,
New Delhi – 110011
Hello,
Kindly provide me with the following information requested under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in respect of complaints against DRDO officials to Hon’ble Prime Minister, PMO.
Implementation of IPR Information System in DRDO – is it exempted organisation for all GOI orders? dated- 28 July 2014
Scraps the promotions for Scientist ‘F’ to Scientist ‘G’ in DRDO year 2011- dated 18 Oct 2014
HR of DRDO – The Great Nuclear Medicine Scientist Dr. A.K. Singh posted as Director of Personnel at DRDO HQ.-dated 16 Oct 2014
Information sought
Status report of the complaints.
Action on the complaints by PMO
Copy of reply of DRDO on subject matter received by PMO
If DRDO not replied till date than copy of reminder to DRDO if any from PMO on subject matter.
